The 10 Best Christian Mystery Books to Read Now

Christian mystery books offer a unique blend of captivating whodunits and thought-provoking spiritual themes. These stories draw you in with their suspenseful twists and turns while gently challenging you to consider deeper questions of faith, morality, and sacrifice. In this article, we’ll explore the growing world of Christian mysteries, and share our top 10 favorites for you to read now.

The 10 Best Christian Mystery Books to Read Now

Why Christian Mystery Books are Worth Exploring

The Christian fiction genre offers a wide variety of subgenres, with mystery and suspense being some of the most popular. Christian mystery books tap into our innate curiosity and fascination with unraveling enigmas, while incorporating values and beliefs that many readers can relate to. But what makes them particularly unique and worth exploring?

The Appeal of Faith-Based Mysteries

The Christian mystery genre offers its readers an intriguing fusion of compelling plotlines and faith-based themes. These stories often involve protagonists dealing with moral struggles and wrestling with questions about their faith as they navigate through the challenges of solving a mystery. This combination of elements ultimately creates a riveting reading experience that not only entertains, but also leaves a lasting impact on the reader.

For instance, in the book “The Case of the Velvet Claws” by Perry Mason, the protagonist, a criminal defense lawyer, is faced with a moral dilemma when he is hired to defend a woman who is accused of blackmailing a wealthy businessman. As he delves deeper into the case, he realizes that his client is not as innocent as she seems, and he must grapple with his own conscience and faith as he decides how to proceed.

Additionally, these stories often highlight the power of redemption, forgiveness, and God’s presence in the midst of hardship. This can help readers find consolation in their own struggles and inspire them to persevere despite the challenges they may face daily.

The Growth of the Christian Mystery Genre

Over the years, Christian  mystery books have experienced a surge in popularity, with more and more talented authors penning captivating stories that cater to this growing demand. As a result, readers now have a diverse selection of titles to choose from, catering to various tastes and preferences.

One such author is Terri Blackstock, who has written numerous bestselling Christian mystery novels, including “If I Run” and “Twisted Innocence. Her books often feature strong female protagonists who must use their faith and wits to solve complex mysteries and overcome personal challenges.

The Christian mystery genre has also expanded beyond its traditional settings, exploring different time periods, cultures, and backgrounds. For example, the book “The Samurai’s Garden” by Gail Tsukiyama is set in Japan during World War II and follows the story of a Chinese man who is sent to live with a Japanese family to recover from tuberculosis (for more great Japanese books, see our guide here). As he learns about Japanese culture and forms relationships with the family members, he becomes embroiled in a mystery involving a local samurai and his missing son.

This cultural diversity adds an additional layer of intrigue, making the genre all the more appealing to a diverse audience.

In conclusion, Christian mystery books offer readers a unique combination of thrilling plotlines and faith-based themes that can leave a lasting impact. With the genre’s growing popularity and diverse selection of titles, there has never been a better time to explore this exciting genre.

Top 5 Classic Christian Mystery Books

For those new to the genre, it’s important to start with the classics – the books that have stood the test of time and continue to be lauded for their creativity and quality. Without further ado, here are our top 5 classic Christian mystery books:

“The Father Brown Mysteries” by G.K. Chesterton

Father Brown Complete Murder Mysteries: The Innocence of Father Brown, The Wisdom of Father Brown, The Donnington Affair…

Arguably the most famous Christian mystery series, G.K. Chesterton’s “Father Brown Mysteries” follows the unassuming Catholic priest Father Brown, who possesses an uncanny knack for solving crimes. Chesterton’s stories are both witty and profound, gracefully weaving together elements of mystery and theology.

Many readers appreciate the intellectual challenge these stories present, and find that they resonate with their own spiritual journeys. With over 50 short stories in the series, you’ll have plenty of rich material to dive into.

One of the most fascinating aspects of the Father Brown series is the way that Chesterton uses the character to explore the intersection of faith and reason. Father Brown is a man of deep faith, but he is also a keen observer of human nature and a master of deductive reasoning. Through his investigations, he demonstrates that faith and reason are not mutually exclusive, but can work together to reveal deeper truths about the world and our place in it.

“The Bishop at the Lake” by Andrew M. Greeley

The Bishop at the Lake: A Bishop Blackie Ryan Novel (Blackie Ryan series Book 16)

Set in a picturesque lakeside community, “The Bishop at the Lake” is a work from Andrew M. Greeley’s extensive “Father Blackwell Chronicles.” This mystery sees the charming Father Blackie Ryan investigating the suspicious drowning of a wealthy resident.

The novel presents a cast of memorable characters and interweaves elements of Catholic theology, making for a delightfully compelling reading experience.

Greeley was a prolific author who wrote over 50 novels in his lifetime, many of them mysteries featuring Catholic priests as detectives. He was known for his ability to blend elements of faith, romance, and suspense into his stories, creating works that were both entertaining and thought-provoking.

“The Hawk and the Dove” by Penelope Wilcock

The Hawk and the Dove (The Hawk and the Dove Series Book 1)

Set in a 14th-century English monastery, “The Hawk and the Dove” weaves together the story of a compassionate abbot and a sorrowful monk facing a web of intrigue and betrayal. The novel is a thought-provoking exploration of themes such as grace, forgiveness, and humility.

With rich, immersive language and fascinating historical details, this book will transport you back in time and leave you pondering its deeper message long after the final page is turned.

Wilcock is a master of historical fiction, and her ability to bring the past to life is on full display in “The Hawk and the Dove.” Through her vivid descriptions of the monastery and its inhabitants, she creates a world that feels both authentic and timeless.

“The Mitford Series” by Jan Karon


The beloved “Mitford Series” chronicles the life and ministry of Father Tim Kavanagh, an Episcopal priest in the small town of Mitford, North Carolina. Over the course of the series, Father Tim encounters mysteries, both great and small, as he shepherds his lively congregation and grapples with his own personal struggles.

These books paint a heartwarming portrait of faith, community, and the beauty of ordinary life, often intermingled with moments of humor and wisdom that will keep you engaged from start to finish.

Karon’s writing is known for its warmth and charm, and the Mitford series is no exception. Through her vivid characters and idyllic setting, she creates a world that readers will want to return to again and again.

“The End of the Affair” by Graham Greene

The End of the Affair

As much a philosophical exploration as it is a gripping mystery, “The End of the Affair” tells the story of Maurice Bendrix and Sarah Miles, whose passionate love affair is cut short by an unexpected tragedy. Following the event, Bendrix becomes consumed with jealousy and suspicion, leading him to hire a private investigator to uncover the truth about Sarah’s sudden departure.

Set against the backdrop of World War II, this novel delves into themes such as faith, doubt, obsession, and forgiveness, masterfully exploring the complexities of human relationships and the nature of love.

Graham Greene was a master of suspense and psychological drama, and “The End of the Affair” is one of his most acclaimed works. Through his exploration of the human heart and its deepest desires, he creates a story that is both haunting and unforgettable.

Top 5 Modern Christian Mystery Books

Now that we’ve covered the classics, let’s turn our attention to some of the best modern Christian mystery books – stories written by contemporary authors who are breathing new life into the genre.

“The House on Foster Hill” by Jaime Jo Wright

The House on Foster Hill

This suspenseful, dual-timeline novel tells the story of two women separated by a century, both drawn to the enigmatic house on Foster Hill. As they unravel the mysteries surrounding the house, they find their stories intertwining in unexpected ways.

With its haunting atmosphere, complex characters, and thought-provoking themes, “The House on Foster Hill” will keep you hooked until its satisfying conclusion.

“A Light on the Hill” by Connilyn Cossette

A Light on the Hill (Cities of Refuge Book #1)

Set in the tumultuous time of ancient Israel, “A Light on the Hill” is a riveting tale of Moriyah, a woman marked by her past and desperately seeking redemption. When a devastating crime threatens to destroy her newfound hope, Moriyah embarks on a perilous journey through the wilderness, battling both physical and spiritual obstacles along the way.

Beautifully written and richly detailed, this novel offers an immersive experience that will transport you to another time and place, all while inspiring deep reflection on the themes of forgiveness and restoration.

“The Masterpiece” by Francine Rivers

The Masterpiece: A Novel (A Redemptive, Character-Driven, Contemporary Christian Fiction Romance Novel)

Roman Velasco, a gifted but tormented artist, and Grace Moore, a struggling single mother, find their lives unexpectedly woven together as they both seek healing and redemption amidst their brokenness. As they navigate their personal struggles, secrets from their past emerge, forcing them to confront their deepest fears and doubts.

The Masterpiece” is written with raw emotion and incredible depth, creating an unforgettable tale that explores life’s messiness and the beauty of God’s transforming grace.

“If I Run” by Terri Blackstock

If I Run (If I Run Series Book 1)

When Casey Cox discovers her best friend’s murdered body, she must make a desperate decision: stay and face suspicion, or run for her life. Meanwhile, investigator Dylan Roberts is determined to find the truth, but as he gets closer to Casey, he becomes convinced of her innocence and must decide where his loyalties lie.

If I Run” is a fast-paced and thrilling mystery that keeps its readers on the edge of their seats, all while exploring themes of trust, friendship, and faith.

“The 49th Mystic” by Ted Dekker

The 49th Mystic (Beyond the Circle Book #1)

Rachelle Matthews, a blind teenager, is plagued by terrifying dreams that seem all too real. When her sight is miraculously restored, she discovers that her ordinary life is anything but, and that she’s at the center of an ancient and epic struggle between darkness and light.

With its fascinating concept, intricate world-building, and deeply developed characters, “The 49th Mystic” is a thrilling read that will have you questioning the nature of reality itself.

Whether you’re new to Christian mystery books or a seasoned fan, these captivating stories are sure to delight and inspire. So, grab a warm blanket, cozy up in your favorite reading spot, and embark on these incredible literary adventures that brilliantly combine mystery, faith, and the transformative power of redemption.


What are Christian mystery novels?

Christian mystery novels are works of fiction written by or about people who practice Christianity. In the process of unraveling the mystery at the heart of the novel, the characters’ faith will be tested. These novels explore belief and the importance of faith during times of hardship.

Which authors write Christian mystery novels?

Fans of the genre often cite Frank Peretti, Eleanor Taylor Bland, and Tom Threadgill as the best writers of Christian mystery stories.

Are Christian mystery novels appropriate for people from different dominations?

Yes, they are. The plots and the characters from this genre can be enjoyed by anyone, there is just a more pronounced focus on the principles of Christian faith.

YouTube video
Eddison Monroe
Latest posts by Eddison Monroe (see all)