The 12 Most Popular Mystery Authors of All Time

Mystery novels have captivated readers for centuries, offering intriguing tales filled with suspense, secrets, and surprises. In this article, we celebrate the best mystery authors that have captivated readers throughout history. From golden age writers to modern masters and international sensations, these authors have crafted unforgettable whodunits that keep us guessing until the very end.

The 12 Most Popular Mystery Authors of All Time

The Golden Age of Mystery Writers

The golden age of mystery novels refers to the period between the two world wars when the genre thrived and produced some of its most iconic and beloved writers. These authors honed their craft, developing unique styles and creating unforgettable characters that live on in the hearts of mystery aficionados today.

The Golden Age of mystery writers was a time of great creativity and innovation in the genre. Writers experimented with new narrative techniques, intricate plots, and memorable characters, creating works that continue to captivate readers today.

Agatha Christie: The Queen of Crime

Murder on the Orient Express: A Hercule Poirot Mystery: The Official Authorized Edition (Hercule Poirot series Book 9)

Agatha Christie is perhaps the most well-known mystery author of all time. Her works have been translated into over 100 languages, and she holds the distinction of being the best-selling novelist in history. Christie’s novels are characterized by their intricate plots and memorable characters, such as Hercule Poirot and Miss Marple.

Christie’s life was as fascinating as her novels. She was born in Torquay, England, in 1890, and began writing at a young age. During World War I, she worked as a nurse, an experience that would later inform her writing. Christie’s first novel, “The Mysterious Affair at Styles,” was published in 1920 and introduced readers to her iconic detective, Hercule Poirot.

Some of her most famous works include “Murder on the Orient Express“, “Death on the Nile“, and “And Then There Were None” Christie’s unique ability to weave intricate plots and craft memorable characters has cemented her status as a legend in the world of mystery storytelling.

Dorothy L. Sayers: Creator of Lord Peter Wimsey

Whose Body? (Lord Peter Wimsey Series Book 1)

Dorothy L. Sayers was an English author, poet, and playwright best known for her Lord Peter Wimsey detective novels. Wimsey, a gentle yet skilled amateur detective, is known for his wit, intelligence, and gentlemanly manners.

Sayers was a woman of many talents. In addition to her writing, she was a scholar of medieval literature and a translator of Dante’s “Divine Comedy.” Her works are characterized by their rich prose and intricate attention to detail, which have earned her a devoted following among mystery enthusiasts.

Some of Sayer’s most popular works include “Whose Body?“, “The Nine Tailors“, and “Gaudy Night.” Her novels are known for their complex plots and well-drawn characters, particularly Lord Peter Wimsey, who has become an enduring figure in the world of detective fiction.

Ellery Queen: The American Detective Fiction Duo

The Roman Hat Mystery

Ellery Queen is the pseudonym for the writing team of cousins Frederic Dannay and Manfred B. Lee. Together, they wrote a series of novels, radio plays, and television episodes featuring their titular character, detective Ellery Queen. Their stories are hallmarked by their use of false clues and twists, often challenging the reader to solve the crime before Queen does.

Dannay and Lee were pioneers in the mystery genre, experimenting with new narrative techniques and creating innovative plots. Their use of “fair play” puzzles, in which all the clues are presented to the reader, challenged readers to solve the mystery alongside Queen.

Popular Ellery Queen works include “The Roman Hat Mystery,” “The French Powder Mystery,” and “The Greek Coffin Mystery.” Their innovative storytelling and clever use of “fair play” puzzles have earned them a lasting legacy in the mystery genre.

Rex Stout: The Man Behind Nero Wolfe

Fer-de-Lance (A Nero Wolfe Mystery Book 1)

Rex Stout was an American writer known for his detective stories featuring the brilliant, eccentric detective Nero Wolfe and his witty sidekick, Archie Goodwin. The Nero Wolfe stories are characterized by their sharp dialogue, vivid settings, and colorful cast of characters.

Stout was a prolific writer, producing over 70 novels and numerous short stories over the course of his career. His engaging storytelling and unforgettable characters have ensured his place among the giants of mystery literature.

Some of Rex Stout’s most beloved novels include “Fer-de-Lance,” “The Doorbell Rang,” and “Too Many Cooks.” Stout’s writing was marked by his attention to detail and his ability to create vivid, memorable characters, particularly Nero Wolfe and Archie Goodwin.

The Golden Age of mystery writers produced some of the most enduring and beloved works in the genre. These writers created characters and stories that continue to captivate readers today, cementing their place in the pantheon of great mystery writers.

Modern Masters of Mystery

While the golden age of mystery writers gave birth to many legends in the field, the genre did not stop evolving. Numerous modern authors have continued to captivate readers with their unique takes on the mystery genre, weaving suspenseful tales that keep fans on their toes.

P.D. James: The British Crime Novelist

The Lighthouse (Adam Dalgliesh Mysteries Book 13)

Phyllis Dorothy James, better known as P.D. James, was a prolific British crime novelist acclaimed for her psychological depth and her creation of the detective Adam Dalgliesh (for more authors like P.D. James, read here). Her novels often focus on the motivations and internal struggles of the characters, providing a rich and complex narrative that deepens the mystery.

James’ writing style is characterized by her attention to detail and her ability to create a vivid sense of place. In her novel “The Lighthouse,” for example, she paints a haunting picture of a remote island off the coast of England, where a murder takes place in a lighthouse that has been converted into a family home. Her descriptions of the rugged landscape and the eerie atmosphere of the lighthouse add to the suspense and create a sense of foreboding that keeps readers on edge.

Another hallmark of James’ writing is her exploration of the psychological motivations of her characters. In “The Children of Men,” for instance, she imagines a dystopian future in which humanity has become infertile. The novel follows the journey of a group of people trying to save the last pregnant woman on earth from those who would use her for their own purposes. James’ exploration of the characters’ fears, hopes, and desires adds a layer of complexity to the mystery and elevates it beyond a simple whodunit.

Ruth Rendell: Psychological Suspense Expert

A Judgement in Stone (Vintage Crime/Black Lizard)

Ruth Rendell was an English author known for her psychological crime novels and her creation of the detective Chief Inspector Wexford. Rendell’s stories often delve into the minds of the criminals, providing readers with a chilling insight into their motivations and thought processes.

One of Rendell’s most notable works is “A Judgement in Stone,” a novel that explores the class divide in England through the lens of a murder investigation. The novel is told from multiple perspectives, including that of the killer, and Rendell’s ability to create empathy for even the most heinous of characters is a testament to her skill as a writer.

Rendell’s writing is also notable for its exploration of social issues. In “Simisola,” for example, she tackles the issue of racism in England through the story of a missing Nigerian student. Her nuanced portrayal of the characters and their interactions adds depth to the mystery and elevates it beyond a simple whodunit.

Sue Grafton: Alphabet Series Pioneer

'A' is for Alibi: A Kinsey Millhone Mystery

Sue Grafton was an American author best known for her Alphabet Series of mystery novels featuring the detective Kinsey Millhone. Each book in the series is named after a letter of the alphabet and a corresponding crime, from “A is for Alibi” to “Y is for Yesterday.”

Grafton’s novels are characterized by their strong, independent heroine and fast-paced plots. In “C is for Corpse,” for example, Kinsey Millhone investigates the death of a wealthy businessman and uncovers a web of deceit and betrayal. Grafton’s ability to create complex, multi-layered plots that keep readers guessing until the very end is a testament to her skill as a writer.

Grafton’s writing is also notable for its attention to detail. In “G is for Gumshoe,” for instance, she delves into the world of insurance fraud and the intricacies of the claims process. Her research and attention to detail add a layer of authenticity to the mystery and make it all the more compelling.

Michael Connelly: Chronicler of Harry Bosch

The Poet: A Novel (Jack McEvoy Book 1)

Michael Connelly, an American author, is best known for his series of crime novels featuring the detective Hieronymus “Harry” Bosch. Connelly’s Bosch stories, set in Los Angeles, are characterized by their gritty realism and intricate, often interconnected plots.

One of Connelly’s most notable works is “The Poet,” a novel that follows journalist Jack McEvoy as he investigates a series of murders that appear to be the work of a serial killer. The novel is notable for its exploration of the psychology of the killer and its depiction of the toll that investigating such crimes can take on those who pursue them.

Connelly’s writing is also notable for its attention to detail and its ability to create a vivid sense of place. In “The Black Echo,” for example, he paints a haunting picture of the underground tunnels beneath Los Angeles, where a murder takes place. His descriptions of the dark, claustrophobic tunnels add to the suspense and create a sense of foreboding that keeps readers on edge.

Overall, these modern masters of mystery have continued to push the boundaries of the genre, creating complex, multi-layered stories that keep readers guessing until the very end. Their unique approaches to the mystery genre and their captivating storytelling have made them highly respected figures in the modern mystery landscape.

International Mystery Writers

While many classic and modern mystery authors hail from English-speaking countries, the genre has an impressive array of international talent. These authors bring their unique cultural perspectives to the table, broadening the scope of mystery literature and taking readers on captivating journeys across the globe.

Jo Nesbø: Norwegian Crime Fiction Star

The Redbreast: A Harry Hole Novel

Jo Nesbø is a Norwegian author best known for his crime novels featuring Detective Harry Hole. Nesbø’s stories are dark and atmospheric, set against the backdrop of Norway’s sprawling landscape and often focusing on themes of political intrigue and corruption.

Popular Jo Nesbø novels include “The Redbreast,” “The Snowman,” and “Police.” Nesbø’s chilling and suspenseful storytelling has earned him critical acclaim and a worldwide following of eager readers.

Henning Mankell: Swedish Detective Fiction Icon

Faceless Killers: A Mystery (Kurt Wallander Mystery Book 1)

Henning Mankell was a Swedish author best known for his series of novels featuring the brooding, introspective detective Kurt Wallander. Set in the small town of Ystad, Mankell’s stories often focus on themes of social justice and the toll that crime takes on individuals and communities.

Some of Henning Mankell’s most notable works include “Faceless Killers,” “The Dogs of Riga,” and “The Fifth Woman.” Mankell’s innovative storytelling and his unique examination of societal issues have made him a renowned figure in international mystery fiction.

Keigo Higashino: Japanese Mystery Maestro

The Devotion of Suspect X: A Detective Galileo Novel (Detective Galileo Series Book 1)

Keigo Higashino is a Japanese author acclaimed for his mystery novels that often blend elements of suspense, police procedural, and puzzle-solving. His stories feature intricate plots and unexpected twists that challenge the reader to unravel the mystery alongside the characters.

Notable Keigo Higashino novels include “The Devotion of Suspect X,” “Journey Under the Midnight Sun,” and “Naoko.” Higashino’s engaging and innovative approach to the mystery genre has gained him a devoted following both in Japan and internationally.

Andrea Camilleri: Italian Inspector Montalbano Creator

The Shape of Water (The Inspector Montalbano Mysteries Book 1)

Andrea Camilleri was an Italian author and screenwriter known for his series of novels featuring the clever, culinary detective Inspector Montalbano. Camilleri’s stories, set in the fictional town of Vigàta in Sicily, are characterized by their humor, vivid characters, and mouth-watering descriptions of Sicilian cuisine.

Some of Andrea Camilleri’s most beloved works include “The Shape of Water,” “The Terracotta Dog,” and “The Voice of the Violin.” Camilleri’s charming and delightful take on the mystery genre has earned him a devoted fan base and widespread critical acclaim.

In conclusion, the world of mystery literature is vast and diverse, featuring a wide range of authors who have crafted distinctive stories that captivate readers around the globe. These authors, both classic and contemporary, have left an indelible mark on the genre and continue to inspire new generations of mystery lovers. Whether you prefer the elegance of golden age detective fiction, the psychological intrigues of modern masters, or the exotic settings of international authors, there is a mystery author out there guaranteed to thrill and intrigue you.


Who are the most famous mystery authors of all time?

Agatha Christie, Gillian Flynn, Arthur Conan Doyle, Stieg Larsson, Tana French, Lee Child, Stephen King, Daphne Du Maurier, and James Patterson are all brilliant and well-known mystery authors.

What is the most popular mystery book ever written?

The highest-selling mystery book of all time is And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie, however, other popular mystery books include The Big Sleep by Raymond Chandler, Rebecca by Daphne Du Maurier, and The Woman in White by Wilkie Collins.

What’s a popular light-hearted mystery?

Richard Osman’s The Thursday Murder Club is a great light-hearted mystery book.

YouTube video
Eddison Monroe
Latest posts by Eddison Monroe (see all)