The 10 Best Book Club Mystery Books

Mystery novels have always been a popular choice for book clubs due to their engaging and intriguing nature. As a genre, mystery provides readers with suspense, exciting plot twists, and the opportunity to flex their deductive skills. In this article, we’ll discuss why mystery books make for the perfect book club selection and introduce you to ten incredible titles—both classic and modern—that’ll keep your group on the edges of their seats.

The 10 Best Book Club Mystery Books

Why Choose Mystery Books for Your Book Club

The Appeal of Mystery Novels

Mystery novels capture the imagination with their intricate plots and well-developed characters. The beauty of the genre lies in its ability to engage readers in a thrilling narrative, enticing them to continually speculate about the outcome. Additionally, mysteries often reveal hidden aspects of human nature, providing food for thought and stimulating discussions.

For example, Agatha Christie’s famous detective, Hercule Poirot, often uncovers the darker side of human nature in her novels. In “Murder on the Orient Express,” Poirot investigates a murder on a train and discovers that all the passengers have motives for the crime. Through Poirot’s investigation, readers are forced to confront the reality that even the most seemingly innocent individuals can be capable of committing heinous acts.

Mystery authors employ a variety of literary techniques—such as foreshadowing and red herrings—to keep readers guessing and turning the pages. Furthermore, the excitement of finally reaching the book’s climax and uncovering the truth behind the puzzle only amplifies the reading experience.

For instance, in Gillian Flynn’s “Gone Girl,” readers are taken on a wild ride as they try to figure out what happened to the missing wife, Amy. Flynn expertly uses flashbacks and unreliable narrators to keep readers guessing until the very end. The twists and turns in the plot make for an exhilarating read that will keep you on the edge of your seat.

Benefits of Reading Mystery Books in a Group

Participating in a book club amplifies the enjoyment derived from mystery novels, as members can share theories, dissect clues, and engage in spirited debates about suspects and motives. This collaborative experience leads to a deeper appreciation of the story and characters, fostering a greater understanding of the author’s intended message.

Moreover, mystery book clubs often attract readers with diverse perspectives, leading to richer discussions and interpretations. By considering different viewpoints and revisiting overlooked details, book club members can unlock new layers of meaning within the story, ultimately resulting in a more satisfying reading experience.

For example, in Tana French’s “In the Woods,” readers are taken on a journey through a murder investigation in Ireland. French’s use of vivid descriptions and complex characters make for a captivating read. In a book club setting, members can discuss the cultural and historical significance of the setting and how it impacts the characters’ motivations and actions.

Additionally, book clubs can also delve into the societal issues that are often explored in mystery novels. For instance, in Walter Mosley’s “Devil in a Blue Dress,” readers are transported to 1940s Los Angeles, where racism and segregation are rampant. The protagonist, Easy Rawlins, is a Black man who is forced to navigate this dangerous world while also solving a mystery. In a book club setting, members can discuss the themes of race and class and how they relate to the story.

In conclusion, mystery books are a fantastic choice for book clubs due to their engaging plots, complex characters, and thought-provoking themes. By reading and discussing these novels with others, readers can deepen their understanding and appreciation of the genre, while also gaining insight into the human condition. So gather your friends, grab a copy of your favorite mystery novel, and get ready for a thrilling ride!

Top 5 Classic Mystery Books for Book Clubs

Mystery novels have been a popular genre for centuries, with countless authors crafting compelling stories that keep readers on the edge of their seats. For book clubs, choosing a classic mystery novel can be an excellent way to engage members in lively discussions and debates. Here are the top five classic mystery books for book clubs:

“And Then There Were None” by Agatha Christie

And Then There Were None

As one of the best-selling mystery novels of all time, Agatha Christie’s masterpiece, “And Then There Were None,” is an excellent place to start. The story revolves around ten strangers who are invited to a secluded island, only to realize they’re being targeted by a mysterious killer. As their numbers dwindle, the survivors scramble to unmask the murderer before it’s too late. This book boasts intricate plotting, a captivating setup, and a classic atmosphere that will have your book club abuzz with theories.

One of the most intriguing aspects of “And Then There Were None” is the way Christie sets up the story. Each of the ten characters is given a detailed backstory, making it difficult to guess who the killer might be. As the plot thickens and the characters start to die off, readers are left guessing until the very end.

“The Hound of the Baskervilles” by Arthur Conan Doyle

The Hound of the Baskervilles (Wisehouse Classics Edition)

Sherlock Holmes is perhaps the most iconic detective in literary history, and “The Hound of the Baskervilles” follows the esteemed sleuth as he unravels the eerie mystery surrounding the Baskerville family curse. With its atmospheric setting on Dartmoor and Holmes’s ingenious deductions, this novel will keep book club members enthralled and lead to ample discussion about the nature of rationality and the supernatural.

One of the most interesting aspects of “The Hound of the Baskervilles” is the way Conan Doyle weaves together elements of the supernatural with Holmes’s logical approach to solving crimes. The story is a masterclass in suspense, with readers never quite sure whether the hound is a real creature or a figment of someone’s imagination.

“Rebecca” by Daphne du Maurier


Rebecca” is a gothic romance and psychological thriller that explores themes of love, jealousy, and deception. When the unnamed protagonist marries wealthy widower Maxim de Winter, she’s haunted by the memory of his deceased first wife, Rebecca. The oppressive atmosphere at Manderley, the de Winter estate, and the enigmatic characters make for an enticing and suspenseful read, prompting lively conversations about character motivations and the novel’s enduring appeal.

One of the most fascinating aspects of “Rebecca” is the way du Maurier creates a sense of foreboding throughout the novel. From the opening lines (“Last night I dreamt I went to Manderley again”) to the final twist, readers are drawn into a world of secrets and intrigue.

“The Maltese Falcon” by Dashiell Hammett

The Maltese Falcon

This hard-boiled detective classic follows private investigator Sam Spade as he navigates the seedy underbelly of San Francisco in search of the elusive Maltese Falcon. From double-crosses to shifting allegiances, “The Maltese Falcon” presents a gritty, intriguing world that will captivate book club members and spark discussions on the book’s impact on the mystery genre.

One of the most notable aspects of “The Maltese Falcon” is the way Hammett portrays the city of San Francisco. The novel is set during the Prohibition era, and Hammett’s descriptions of speakeasies and gangsters give readers a glimpse into a fascinating period of American history.

“The Murder of Roger Ackroyd” by Agatha Christie

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd (Illustrated): A case for Hercule Poirot

Another Christie classic, “The Murder of Roger Ackroyd,” features the brilliant Belgian detective Hercule Poirot as he investigates the shocking murder of wealthy businessman Roger Ackroyd. With its innovative narrative structure and an unforgettable twist ending, this novel will keep book club members debating the ethics of the story and the implications of the surprising conclusion.

One of the most intriguing aspects of “The Murder of Roger Ackroyd” is the way Christie plays with the conventions of the mystery genre. The novel is narrated by Dr. James Sheppard, a friend of Poirot’s who is intimately involved in the investigation. As the story unfolds, readers are forced to question their assumptions about who is telling the truth and who is hiding something.

Overall, these five classic mystery novels are sure to spark lively discussions and debates among book club members. From the intricate plotting of Agatha Christie to the atmospheric settings of Arthur Conan Doyle and Daphne du Maurier, these books are sure to keep readers engaged and entertained.

Top 5 Modern Mystery Books for Book Clubs

“Gone Girl” by Gillian Flynn

Gone Girl: A Novel

A gripping and twisty thriller, “Gone Girl” tells the story of Nick and Amy Dunne’s turbulent marriage and the events surrounding Amy’s sudden disappearance. Flynn unspools her intricate narrative through alternating perspectives, leaving readers unsure of who to trust. As the book’s many twists are revealed, book club members will find themselves constantly reevaluating characters and revising their assumptions.

“The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo” by Stieg Larsson

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo: A Lisbeth Salander Novel (The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo Series Book 1)

This dark and atmospheric mystery follows investigative journalist Mikael Blomkvist and punk hacker Lisbeth Salander as they dive into the decades-old Vanisher case of Harriet Vanger. With its complex characters and a multi-layered plot, “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo” will lead to enthusiastic debates about the novel’s themes and the innovative ways in which it subverts traditional mystery tropes.

“Big Little Lies” by Liane Moriarty

Big Little Lies

In “Big Little Lies,” Moriarty masterfully weaves a tale of murder, secrets, and deception that follows three women whose lives become entangled in a web of lies. With its relatable and compelling characters, the book provides readers with plenty of discussion fodder, exploring themes such as societal expectations, domestic violence, and the complexity of friendship.

“The Cuckoo’s Calling” by Robert Galbraith

The Cuckoo's Calling (Cormoran Strike Book 1)

Robert Galbraith, a pseudonym for J.K. Rowling, introduces private investigator Cormoran Strike in this engaging mystery. When a famous model falls to her death in an apparent suicide, Strike is hired to investigate the shady circumstances surrounding her demise. As he delves into the world of celebrity, secrets come to light, and book club members will find themselves engrossed in the twists and turns of this modern detective tale.

You can find this book here.

“The Silent Patient” by Alex Michaelides

The Silent Patient

A psychological thriller with a shocking twist, “The Silent Patient” follows psychotherapist Theo Faber as he tries to treat Alicia Berenson, a patient who has remained mute since being charged with her husband’s murder. The novel unravels the mystery surrounding Alicia’s past as Theo becomes increasingly obsessed with her case. Book club members will enjoy dissecting the many layers of this complex tale and debating the novel’s exploration of trust, memory, and obsession.

From classic masterpieces to modern gems, these ten mystery novels offer a thrilling array of choices for your next book club gathering. Immerse yourselves in worlds filled with intrigue, suspense, and unforgettable characters that are sure to spark conversation and foster meaningful connections among members. Happy reading!


What is a book club?

A book club, also referred to as a book group, describes a group of people who meet on a regular basis to discuss a book they have all read. Typically the members will take turns picking the books and discussion questions. It is a fun way to combine socializing with a love of literature.

Why are mysteries so good for book clubs?

Mysteries are an excellent choice for book clubs because members can discuss various clues and hints they picked up on and whether they were able to unravel the mystery on their own.

Is a cozy mystery or a dark mystery better for a book club?

It really depends on the book club and what themes the members are interested in. Sometimes people will want a lighthearted read whereas, at other times, people will want a gripping narrative filled with tension.

YouTube video
Eddison Monroe
Latest posts by Eddison Monroe (see all)