Discover the Best Gay Mystery Books (Queer Thrillers)

Gay mystery fiction has come a long way over the years. From early pioneers to modern voices breaking boundaries, LGBTQ+ representation in the mystery genre has evolved significantly. In this article, we’ll take a closer look at the different subgenres of gay mystery and explore some of the most exciting titles out there. Whether you’re a long-time fan of the genre or new to it, these must-read books are sure to deliver a thrilling experience.

Discover the Best Gay Mystery Books for a Thrilling Read

The Evolution of LGBTQ+ Representation in Mystery Novels

The mystery genre has a long and storied history, filled with crime, suspense, and intrigue. However, for many years, LGBTQ+ representation was not a part of this world. It wasn’t until the late 20th century that early pioneers in gay mystery fiction began to emerge.

Early Pioneers in Gay Mystery Fiction

Fadeout (A Dave Brandstetter Mystery Book 1)

One of the earliest and most well-known pioneers of gay mystery fiction was Joseph Hansen, whose series of novels featuring detective Dave Brandstetter debuted in 1970. Hansen’s stories were groundbreaking for their time, as they featured a gay protagonist who navigated both the sleuthing world and the complexities of his personal life.

Hansen’s work was followed by other writers who also broke ground in the genre. Michael Nava and Katherine V. Forrest, for example, created stories that explored LGBTQ+ themes in new and innovative ways. These early writers paved the way for the next generation of queer sleuths.

The Rise of Queer Detectives and Sleuths

Indemnity Only: A V. I. Warshawski Novel (30th Anniversary Edition) (V.I. Warshawski Novels Book 1)

As LGBTQ+ representation became more mainstream, so too did the characters within the mystery genre. One notable example is Sara Paretsky’s series featuring private detective V. I. Warshawski, who made her debut in 1982. Though Warshawski’s sexuality is not a central focus of the series, her inclusion as a queer female character helped to expand representation within the genre.

Since then, a wide range of queer sleuths and detectives have emerged, each bringing their unique perspectives and experiences to the world of mystery fiction. From transgender private investigator Robin Cassidy in J.M. Redmann’s Micky Knight series to the lesbian duo of Nic and Nigel Martini in Tracy Kiely’s cozy mysteries, there truly is something for everyone.

Modern LGBTQ+ Mystery Authors Breaking Boundaries

The Last Place You Look: A Mystery (Roxane Weary Book 1)

Today, there are more LGBTQ+ mystery authors than ever before, and they continue to expand and innovate within the genre. Some notable names include Greg Herren, whose series of novels featuring private investigator Scotty Bradley explore the seedy underbelly of New Orleans, and Kristen Lepionka, who introduces the world to bisexual private investigator Roxane Weary in her debut novel “The Last Place You Look“. These authors and many others are keeping the tradition of groundbreaking LGBTQ+ mystery fiction alive and well.

Despite the progress that has been made, there is still much work to be done to ensure that LGBTQ+ voices are heard and represented within the mystery genre. However, with each new book and each new author, the world of mystery fiction becomes more diverse and more inclusive, reflecting the rich and varied experiences of all readers.

Top 10 Must-Read Gay Mystery Books

If you’re looking to dive into the world of LGBTQ+ mystery fiction, you’re in for a treat. From classic novels to contemporary reads, there are plenty of great books out there to choose from. Here are 10 must-read gay mystery books to start with:

Classic Gay Mystery Novels

If you’re a fan of classic mystery novels and looking for LGBTQ+ representation, these books are for you:

  1. Fadeout” by Joseph Hansen – This 1970 novel is the first in the Dave Brandstetter series, featuring a gay insurance investigator who solves crimes while navigating his own personal life. Hansen’s writing is praised for its realistic and nuanced portrayal of LGBTQ+ characters.
  2. The Private Eye” by Jaye Maimon – This 1989 novel follows a gay private investigator named Nick Madrid as he investigates a murder case in Los Angeles. Maimon’s writing is known for its witty dialogue and engaging plot twists.
  3. Death Claims” by Joseph Hansen – Another entry in the Dave Brandstetter series, this 1973 novel sees the detective investigating a suspicious car accident that may have been a murder. Hansen’s writing is praised for its attention to detail and character development.

Contemporary Gay Mystery Books

If you’re looking for more recent LGBTQ+ mystery fiction, these books are a great place to start:

  1. The Last Place You Look” by Kristen Lepionka – This 2017 novel follows private investigator Roxane Weary as she investigates a missing person case that hits close to home. Lepionka’s writing is praised for its gripping plot and well-drawn characters.
  2. The Scotty Bradley Series” by Greg Herren – This series of novels follows New Orleans-based private investigator Scotty Bradley as he solves crimes and navigates his personal life. Herren’s writing is praised for its humor and vivid setting descriptions.
  3. “Mystery of the Tempest” by James Lear – This 2019 novel is a historical mystery set in 18th century England, featuring a gay protagonist named Lord Oliver de Lacey. Lear’s writing is praised for its attention to historical detail and engaging plot.

Up-and-Coming Gay Mystery Authors to Watch

If you’re looking for new voices in LGBTQ+ mystery fiction, these authors are worth checking out:

  1. The Mason Braithwaite Paranormal Mystery Series” by Christopher Church – This series of novels follows a gay paranormal investigator named Mason Braithwaite as he solves supernatural mysteries. Church’s writing is praised for its unique blend of mystery and horror elements.
  2. The Nicky and Noah Mysteries” by Joe Cosentino – This series of novels follows theater professor Nicky Abbondanza and his husband Noah Oliver as they solve murders on a college campus. Cosentino’s writing is praised for its humor and engaging characters.
  3. “The Eric and the Black Inspector” series by Victor J. Banis – This series of novels follows a gay private investigator named Eric and his partner, the Black Inspector, as they solve crimes in San Francisco. Banis’s writing is praised for its fast-paced action and well-drawn characters.

With so many great books to choose from, there’s never been a better time to dive into the world of LGBTQ+ mystery fiction. Happy reading!

Exploring Different Subgenres of Gay Mystery

Mystery fiction is a genre that has enthralled readers for centuries, and within it, there are many subgenres that cater to a wide range of interests. Gay mystery is a subgenre that specifically features LGBTQ+ characters and themes, and it has been gaining popularity in recent years. Here are some of the different subgenres of gay mystery that you can explore:

Police Procedurals with LGBTQ+ Leads

The Mark Manning Mysteries

Police procedurals are a popular subgenre in mystery fiction, and there are a number of LGBTQ+ authors and characters within this category. One standout example is Michael Craft’s “Mark Manning” series, which features an openly gay police detective as the lead character. The series is known for its realistic portrayal of police work and its engaging mysteries that keep readers on the edge of their seats.

Other notable police procedural series with LGBTQ+ leads include Neil Plakcy’s “Mahu” series, which follows a gay police detective in Hawaii, and Joseph Hansen’s “Dave Brandstetter” series, which features a gay insurance investigator.

Cozy Mysteries Featuring Queer Characters

All's Fair

Cozy mysteries offer a less intense take on the mystery genre, often featuring amateur sleuths and lighthearted storytelling. There are a growing number of cozy mystery series featuring queer characters, including Josh Lanyon’s “All’s Fair” series, which follows a gay art thief turned amateur detective, and J.C. Eaton’s “Sophie Kimball Mystery” series, which features a lesbian protagonist who works as an editor at a publishing company.

Cozy mysteries are perfect for readers who want to solve a mystery without feeling overwhelmed by the intensity of the plot. They offer a chance to get to know the characters and their quirks, while still providing a satisfying mystery to solve.

Paranormal and Supernatural Gay Mysteries

The Back Passage

For readers who enjoy a touch of the supernatural in their mystery fiction, there are several great options within the LGBTQ+ subgenre. James Lear’s “The Back Passage” explores a murder mystery within the context of an Edwardian homoerotic sex club, while Michael Thomas Ford’s “The Novelty Maker” introduces a murder-mystery set against a backdrop of magical realism.

Other notable paranormal and supernatural gay mystery novels include Jordan Castillo Price’s “PsyCop” series, which follows a gay detective who can see and communicate with ghosts, and Josh Lanyon’s “The Ghost Wore Yellow Socks” which features a gay artist who becomes embroiled in a murder mystery while on vacation in a remote cabin.

Historical Gay Mystery Novels

The Boy Detective & The Summer of 74

Historical fiction and mystery make a great pair, and there are several LGBTQ+ authors working within this subgenre. Art Taylor’s Lambda Literary Award-winning short story collection “The Boy Detective & The Summer of ’74 and Other Tales of Suspense” features queer characters in various historical settings, while Eleanor Kuhns’ historical mystery series set in the late 18th century features a lesbian protagonist.

Other notable historical gay mystery novels include Sarah Waters’ “Fingersmith” which is set in Victorian England and features a lesbian protagonist who becomes embroiled in a complex con, and Alex Grecian’s “The Yard,” which is set in Victorian London and features a gay detective who must solve a series of gruesome murders.

Whether you prefer police procedurals, cozy mysteries, paranormal and supernatural stories, or historical fiction, there is a gay mystery novel out there for you. These subgenres offer a unique perspective on the mystery genre, and they are a great way to explore LGBTQ+ themes and characters in a new and exciting way.

The Importance of Diverse Representation in Mystery Fiction

The value of diverse representation in fiction cannot be overstated. For LGBTQ+ readers, seeing themselves reflected within the pages of a novel can be immensely validating and empowering. And for readers who may not identify as LGBTQ+, exposure to new perspectives and experiences can broaden their understanding and empathy.

Challenging Stereotypes and Tropes

One of the ways diverse representation can be so powerful is by challenging stereotypes and tropes. By presenting complex, multidimensional characters who happen to be LGBTQ+, authors can undermine harmful stereotypes and expand readers’ understanding of the LGBTQ+ community.

The Impact of Authentic LGBTQ+ Characters

Authenticity is key when it comes to LGBTQ+ representation. By portraying characters who are three-dimensional, nuanced, and realistic, authors can create a powerful connection between readers and the story they’re telling. When LGBTQ+ characters are portrayed in a way that feels authentic and true to life, readers are more likely to connect with them on a deeper level.

Encouraging More Inclusive Storytelling in the Mystery Genre

As LGBTQ+ representation in the mystery genre continues to grow and evolve, it’s important to encourage more inclusive storytelling. By supporting LGBTQ+ authors and advocating for greater diversity in the books we read, we can help foster a more inclusive literary landscape. And who knows? Perhaps the next great queer sleuth is just waiting to be discovered.

Whether you’re a fan of classic noir, modern thrillers, or supernatural mysteries, there’s something for everyone in the world of gay mystery fiction. So why not dive in and discover your next favorite read?


What are gay mystery novels?

Gay mysteries refer to books that feature standard mystery plot lines and include gay characters. The detective, victim, or killer can be gay but the story must include at least one gay character and/or relationship to be classed as a gay mystery.

What is a popular example of a gay mystery novel?

The Dave Brandstetter series written by Joseph Hansen is known as one of the most popular gay mysteries. It was written in the 1970s, so the allusions to homosexuality are more subtle than some may wish.

YouTube video
Eddison Monroe